Tuesday, 17 November 2026

Sharp practice or just good business?

By Artur Nadolny on X, retweeted by Subrosa:

What happened today is very important. has published a story, reporting that the Metropolitan Police is investigating the sale of a hotel by a bank's property arm. I believe it could set a precedent for other small businesses that dealt with the same bank unit. Andy Agathangelou of the shares that view and says a case like this, if won in court, could be followed by others. 16 years. That is how long Chris RIchardson has been fighting over what happened to his business and the Coniston Hotel in Kent. He lost in the civil courts. His complaint to City of London Police was closed. Over the years he was told, in one form or another, that the matter was finished. It was not finished. The Metropolitan Police is now investigating his allegations of fraud. Detectives have sought a High Court production order to get documents from the bank about its 2011 purchase of the hotel. The Times reports it. There have been no arrests or charges so far. Here is the background, so nobody gets lost. The Coniston Hotel near Sittingbourne went into administration in 2010. Its bank was RBS, now part of NatWest Group. The bank's Global Restructuring Group, known as GRG, handled the case. Then West Register, the bank's own property arm, bought the hotel. The hotel went on the market for £3.9M and West Register won the bidding with £4.2M in cash. NatWest says that was the highest of six bids in an open process run by Knight Frank. The interesting part? In 2018 a regulatory investigation commissioned by the Financial Conduct Authority looked at GRG. According to The Times, it found the Coniston case was an extreme example of West Register helping to shape GRG's approach to individual cases. It found meeting minutes recording that a West Register representative talked down the value of the hotel in a discussion with the bank, insolvency practitioners and valuers before the Coniston entered insolvency. It found West Register was in a position to influence key people before a strategy was decided, and in its view did so.. So the bank's own property arm took part in the discussion about what the hotel was worth, and then bought the hotel. Nothing unusual there, apparently. The same review found that GRG, set up to turn struggling companies around, systematically mistreated many of them after the financial crisis. It found GRG targeted them for fee extraction and even reacquired their assets for itself. A turnaround unit that mistreated the businesses it was meant to rescue. Impressive work. Then .. the records. The Times reports that Promontory, which carried out the work for the FCA, has destroyed documents. The bank still holds them. Detectives want documents including the meeting minutes behind the review's conclusions. So the police now have to ask the bank for what the regulator's own reviewer has reportedly destroyed. A tidy arrangement for everyone except the customer. Chris Richardson says the courts and City of London Police never had access to the Promontory documents the Met is now asking for. By his account, he spent 16 years trying to prove his case without them. He says the fight has taken a devastating toll on his health and put his family under unimaginable strain. Here is NatWest's position. It says it will co-operate fully with the production order. It says courts have considered and dismissed the allegations many times and that City of London Police found no basis for them.. Chris Richardson says those courts and police never had access to the Promontory documents the Met is now asking for. If he is right, every earlier dismissal was reached without that evidence. It says the Promontory review found no evidence of properties being bought at a price clearly below market value. In 2014 the Court of Appeal found there was no evidence that the Knight Frank valuation could not be properly relied on. The Met says it reopened the matter in June 2026 after a review found further lines of inquiry, and that it is investigating alleged fraud offences from June 2011. Now the questions ?! If evidence relevant to allegations this serious was destroyed, who authorised it? What did the Financial Conduct Authority know? What records still survive? How many other GRG customers have hit the same wall when trying to prove what happened to their businesses? I make no claim about the answers. The questions still need answering. The FCA commissions a review. Its reviewer destroys papers.. A customer waits 16 years. The police then ask the bank for copies. If that is how accountability works, small businesses have every reason to ask who is accountable to them. Chris Richardson's persistence deserves enormous respect. James Hurley of The Times deserves credit for investigating cases that powerful institutions would probably prefer everyone forgot. Andy Agathangelou of the Transparency Task Force sees this case as potentially important for others, and his group will discuss it on Thursday 19 November at 5pm. Lorraine M. Morris says Ulster Bank's GRG Ireland deserves the same scrutiny.



JH: In other news, today is scheduled for the power outage which the govt assures us is only in America. Many banks are already down over there ... Chase, Wells Fargo etc. Have a great Tuesday, all.

No comments:

Post a Comment

A reminder, dear reader, that you're welcome to comment as Anon but if so, please invent a moniker to appear somewhere in your text ... it tells Watchers nothing, it does help the readers.